Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Embryonic Stem Cell Research
Darkside_RG > Community Forums > Banana Republic
Affinity
From the Guardian:

QUOTE
...

Lawyers for an alliance of Christian groups who brought the case, which tied opposition to experiments on embryonic stem cells to the anti-abortion campaign, said the ruling appeared to go further than restrictions under President George Bush and bar all government funding for such research. It also pushes the ever-contentious issue of abortion to the fore again in the runup to November's mid-term elections and presents Obama with the difficult choice of whether he wants a battle in the courts and in Congress to repeal the legislation.

The court order came after an executive order by Obama in March last year that lifted restrictions put in place by Bush eight years earlier. Those restrictions limited government funding to a small number of existing lines of human embryonic stem cells. The administration had allocated about $250m (£160m) to the research. The National Institutes of Health added an additional 70 lines after Obama's order. But Judge Royce Lamberth ruled that the president's decision was in conflict with the Dickey-Wicker amendment, a 1996 law that bars the use of government funds for "research in which a human embryo or embryos are destroyed". The law has been renewed by Congress each year.

...


Personally, I think it's ridiculous that the progress of medical research is being hindered because of something as silly as the issue of destroying embryonic stem cells. I had thought we were finally beyond these issues, but I guess not. I'm curious to see what your opinions on the matter are, especially anyone who is against the research.
LaoTzu
Firstly, I would like to say that the US governmental and political system is not separate from religion. The separation of church and state is a fallacy. That being said, I will now say that US stem cell policy is based on unfounded religious belief. If you were to look at Chinese stem cell policy, you would find it is considerably more lax than that of the Western world. I can see China significantly surpassing the Western world when it comes to stem cell research.

I, personally, have no problem with stem cell research, whatsoever, but I can also see that those cell will end up dead either way, whether they are used for research, thrown in the garbage, or incinerated. If they are going to end up dead either way, why not get some use out of them?
subman
I feel the same way. Religion != politics. There should be no reason for a bar to be placed over any scientific experiment. Especially this research. Research that could forever change the way people live and grow up.
macjd527
I guarntee that some private corp, and or if not the US government it self is doing stem cell research regardless of the "laws". It isnt like corporations or the government doesnt break laws everyday anyway. Saying that it is not going on and is illegal or whatever, is just a front to keep whatever parties happy.
knightron
Back in December 2003 One of My best friends was diagnosed with Multiple Myloma..(A type of Bone cancer) he was told he would not live over 12 months and to basically get his life in order and prepare to Die....I went to see him in his Pub a few weeks ago ..he was treated with stem cells in 2004 and has gone from strength to strength..while it has not cured him it has certainly given him a chance to see his Grand daughter and live a great life up to press.. drinks.gif good.gif While the stem cells he was treated with were his own( Not embryonic) the method used to collect them and the methods used to re-administer them and the systems and protocols were created by scientists experimenting on Embryo`s. I would like to meet the people with this religious intent and tell them of My Buddy Dave and see what they have to say....I cannot believe that in 2010 people still believe in a omni-present power/God.. whoknows.gif .(I say that in loose terms) who allows WAR,DEATH and Destruction to ravage the world and still go to church, Mosque or synagogue and Pay and pray for this God of theirs to give them solice...Just seems weird to me.!
LaoTzu
Knightron, can you expand on your last post, please? I'd like to hear a little more about the last half.
knightron
If embryonic research was halted on the grounds of.." Its wrong because the embryo`s are human" or "its against our Religious beliefs"..Nothing would have been done to enable scientists to get the where they are now,i.e have the ability to perform such stem cell transplants.or Indeed most of the medical research done in the last 30 years.
We Have to remember as far as science understands at the moment Embryo`s are unable to feel anything,they have no sentience (self awareness), and if people with a religious attitude towards it say " thats just what we know now"..My answer would be this.."Ask your God( which ever one you pray to,) to come and tell you exactly how a ebryo feel`s" if there is any "God" and he is Omni present and knows all ..ask him..! ..Untill such a time we cannot have people halting genuine Medical research on the grounds of their religious beliefs..to do so would not only be unfair to people who don`t believe,but it would be a travesty to all on Earth who rely on medicine to keep them alive...
I am not talking about vivisection here,nor am I talking about medical research to find out if a certain perfume or cosmetic will give you a rash or have somesort of bad reaction on anyone..I mean REAL genuine medical research that attempts to take mankind forward and give the people of the world a better chance of survival if/when they fall ill or become infected with some kind of disese..
LaoTzu
QUOTE (knightron @ Oct 11 2010, 02:12 PM) *
..Untill such a time we cannot have people halting genuine Medical research on the grounds of their religious beliefs..to do so would not only be unfair to people who don`t believe,but it would be a travesty to all on Earth who rely on medicine to keep them alive...


Very well said.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2012 Invision Power Services, Inc.